[
Hanoi, Vietnam – In Hanoi's Thanh Xuan district, the place labyrinthine alleys bustle with residential life and college college students, recollections of final 12 months's lethal house hearth are recent.
Late on September 12, 2023, a fireplace broke out in an house constructing on Khuong Ha Road in Khuong Dinh Ward, killing 56 folks, together with 4 kids.
Police decided that the fireplace began from a brief circuit within the electrical wiring of a scooter parked on the primary flooring, which quickly unfold to the higher flooring of the constructing – the constructing's proprietor added to it to create smaller sub-divided flats, by which Thrice extra tenants might dwell there.
For years, micro-apartments, referred to as “chung cu mini”, have sprouted up in metropolises throughout Vietnam, pushing low-income households and faculty college students into substandard, fire-prone housing.
“These flats are like mushrooms, they’re in all places,” Lan Vo, a former resident of a micro-apartment in Thanh Xuan, advised Al Jazeera, requesting to be referred to by a pseudonym to keep away from harassment.
In an interview with state media final 12 months, Le Hoang Chau, chairman of the Ho Chi Minh Metropolis Actual Property Affiliation, attributed the increase in micro-apartments since 2010 to a scarcity of houses for low-income folks.
The September catastrophe and different fires in micro-apartment blocks have pressured Vietnamese authorities to confront the risks of lax constructing and hearth rules and the inadequacies of the nation's social housing infrastructure.
However because the nation mourns these killed and authorities inspections happen throughout the nation, municipalities discover themselves uneasy about outlawing the constructions due to the scarce affordability they supply to low-income city residents. Feeling.
Blocks of micro-apartments are normally designed within the model of a protracted, slim tube. Constructed on small plots in slim streets of densely populated districts, the housing is commonly positioned near universities and college students and low-income households.
The Ho Chi Minh Metropolis Development Division estimates that by mid-2022 there might be greater than 60,000 micro-apartment buildings within the monetary capital, composed of roughly 600,000 flats.
Chau, chairman of the true property affiliation, stated in his interview with state media that about 1.8 million folks dwell in flats and about 40 % of the workforce in Ho Chi Minh Metropolis alone.
Town police division has reported that roughly 42,200 micro-apartments are at the moment available on the market for hire.
Though there isn’t any official knowledge for Hanoi, in line with the nationwide utility, Vietnam Electrical energy, not less than 2000 micro-apartment buildings are linked to town's energy grid.
On a current go to to Khuong Dinh Ward, the location of the September hearth, Al Jazeera noticed dozens of flats jammed into slim streets.
Different clusters of flats could be present in districts positioned close to universities, reminiscent of Hoang Mai, Cau Giay, Bac Tu Liem and Nam Tu Liem.
“(The tenants) are largely younger employees and plenty of college students dwelling collectively,” stated Vo, a former micro-apartment resident.
“As a result of excessive rents, college students typically dwell collectively in teams of three to 5 folks to share hire and utilities.”
The promoting value of a micro-apartment could be as little as 600 million Vietnamese dongs ($24,615), making housing the most affordable type of property obtainable in most Vietnamese cities.
But, in Vietnam, the place the minimal wage barely reaches $200 a month, tenants — particularly faculty college students — should still battle to seek out themselves paying hire.
Whereas she was comparatively glad together with her lodging, she additionally noticed others who confronted far worse situations than she did.
“The constructing I lived in had about eight to 10 rooms, however the constructing subsequent to mine had 30 rooms,” Vo stated.
“Grasping landlords attempt to stuff as many individuals as attainable in an effort to get greater rents, it appears to be like like a can of sardines if you concentrate on it,” he stated.
For residents, the need to cram increasingly tenants into buildings jeopardizes not solely their consolation, but additionally their security.
In lots of instances the slim and congested streets internet hosting buildings restrict the attain of firefighting autos. Some flats lack emergency exits and different hearth prevention options.
Within the case of the September hearth on Khuong Ha Road, hearth engines and first responders reportedly had issue reaching flats as a result of narrowness of the ward's streets.
Vo stated that tenants in her ward typically gathered for “hearth security drills”, however the drills – which largely consisted of fireside prevention measures, reminiscent of not leaving stoves on – included an absence of emergency escape ladders on buildings. Light due to.
Thuy Hai, a Hanoi College scholar who lives in a micro-apartment, stated there aren’t any month-to-month hearth drills in her ward in Thanh Xuan.
“As a substitute, they (the owner) left a fireplace extinguisher at my entrance door,” she advised Al Jazeera. “They didn't even educate me use it.”
“Tiger cages”, steel rods round home windows and balconies designed to stop theft and falls, have additionally been highlighted as a security hazard.
In September alone, there have been 5 fires of various depth in Hanoi, in line with a state media report.
Colonel Duong Duc Hai, deputy director of the Hanoi Police Division, advised the native outlet that the foundation explanation for 96 % of those fires had been electrical brief circuits.
Tenants' scooters are sometimes positioned on the decrease flooring of house buildings, creating potential security hazards together with blocked vents and electrical malfunctions.
A witness to the Thanh Xuan hearth in September advised Al Jazeera that the constructing's proprietor, Nghiem Quang Minh, had employed an aged safety guard to take care of the scooters of tenants on the bottom flooring, however he would typically test on the variety of autos. Was overwhelmed by.
The witness stated the safety guard was paid in line with the variety of scooters he was capable of park, encouraging him to park as many scooters as attainable.
It was additionally discovered that property homeowners had constructed further flooring and rooms, breaking contract agreements and guidelines.
Minh, who’s now being prosecuted for alleged hearth code violations, constructed not less than eight different micro-apartment buildings in a number of districts of Hanoi, in line with regulation enforcement officers.
State media reported that not one of the flats met hearth security requirements and all had been discovered to have unauthorized constructing extensions.
For years, Vietnamese regulation didn’t outline micro-apartments or embody them beneath any particular authorized framework. This modified in November when the Nationwide Meeting amended the regulation to present them authorized standing.
When the amendments come into pressure on January 1, 2025, property builders will nonetheless be allowed to construct micro-apartments on residential land over which they’ve land use rights.
The amendments set out situations for “particular person” builders to assemble and personal buildings.
Below the foundations, particular person traders will face better hurdles in growing micro-apartments than established actual property companies, together with a minimal funding capital requirement.
Earlier than the authorized modifications, lawmakers debated whether or not strict rules on micro-apartments could be unenforceable or whether or not they need to even be authorized.
Trinh Xuan An, a consultant of the Nationwide Meeting, advised native media that the federal government “shouldn’t assist the development of mini house buildings, however as an alternative, assist the event of social housing initiatives for low-income folks”.
Different MPs harassed that every one the brand new guidelines would permit renters to soundly entry well-liked sorts of housing.
A recurring issue within the debate is affordability.
In Hanoi, quickly rising inhabitants has turned town into one of the densely populated city areas on the earth.
For a lot of budget-conscious renters, the dearth of suburban housing choices makes micro-apartments a pure selection.
Regardless of their dangers, the cramped items have confirmed well-liked amongst college students and low-income, blue-collar employees.
Ex-tenant Vo stated flats had been nonetheless a greater choice than social housing for folks like him and that tighter regulation could be a greater choice than restrictions.
“Tenants ought to be capable to ship complaints straight about critical issues and never have to attend many years for the federal government to reply, particularly relating to their very own security,” he stated.