[
There is nothing above the vigilante police, not even a Giacomo Puccini opera masterpiece.
Turandot, set in ancient China, is about Calaf, a prince of Tartary, who falls in love with a Chinese princess, Turandot. To win the right to marry her, Calaf must answer three riddles. If he fails he will be hanged. If he fails, he will be hanged.
Although Puccini died in 1924, leaving the opera incomplete at the time of his death in 1924, the music was completed posthumously by Franco Alfano and begun in 1926.
However, program notes on the New York Metropolitan Opera's website call “Turandot” a “problematic masterpiece” that co-opts, glamorizes and appropriates Chinese culture.
With his death on November 29, 1924, Giacomo Puccini not only left his latest and most ambitious project unfinished, but also left the world without a clear successor to carry on the grand tradition of Italian opera – a tradition that all It was kind of spread out. The origins of the art form in Renaissance Florence. but while turandot This designation fails to account for how much of the work can be considered “the last great Italian opera”. Not there. Italian. From its setting to its plot and, most importantly, much of its music, turandot is based on other cultures – as Puccini did throughout his career – and represents a distinct development from the previous three centuries of Italian opera. Yet it is by no means authentically Chinese. A Western projection of the East, it is full of contradictions, distortions and racial stereotypes – and yet it remains one of the most stirring and influential works ever to appear on the operatic stage.
,
We should also consider those criticisms turandot-And in recent years Puccini has received appropriation, reworking and recombination of Chinese music. As Ping-Hui Liao, professor of literary and critical studies at the University of California, San Diego, argues, despite the composer's efforts at authenticity, “when material is taken from another culture, as is the case madama butterfly Or turandot, it is integrated and organized so that it becomes intelligible, controlled and acceptable… The melodies are so well integrated that they lose their autonomy and become part of a larger whole. In distinguishing between East and West,[Puccini]subordinates the East to the West.” Or, as Carner sarcastically suggests, whereas the Chinese language characters “put on nationwide musical costume all through… This gown could have the trademark 'Made in Italy'.” It shouldn’t be shocking that many viewers of Chinese language descent discover it tough to observe as their very own heritage is co-opted, fetishized, or portrayed as savage, bloodthirsty, or backward.
Then the query arises easy methods to respect turandot– which incorporates a few of Puccini's most fascinating melodies, scenes of really exceptional musical and dramatic grandeur and alternatives for the show-stopping vocal shows which are on the core of the artwork type's enchantment – in a approach that each celebrates his achievements and Acknowledges the issues inherent in it. As we increase our collective consciousness about its flaws, it’s important that, moderately than shying away from the less-savory features of the opera, with every subsequent revival, audiences acknowledge and grapple with their implications. Solely via consciousness and dialog, which should quickly increase to incorporate a variety of voices and views, can the world really perceive turandot It's an exhilarating however problematic masterpiece.
The New York Submit reviews:
“I've by no means heard of any warnings like this on any opera,” mentioned soprano Atara Hazan, 88, who carried out on the Met and performed Turnadot within the Nineteen Eighties.
The Met has turn out to be very delicate to numerous issues,” mentioned Hazan, who nonetheless works as a voice coach in Manhattan.
Critic and proprietor of the influential music weblog Slipped Disc Norman LeBrecht dismissed this system observe as “manufactured racial incitement”.
“Set off warnings exist to cowl the rising authorized issues of theater directors and the just lately elevated sensitivity of low-paid assistants. They’re dangerous for enterprise and ought to be abolished,” he mentioned.
“There are imaginary Chinese language characters in Turandot. If it bothers you, keep away,'' he mentioned.
Watch the finale of the New York Metropolitan Opera's efficiency of Turandot in 2009.