Flashback: Invoice O'Reilly and Geraldo Rivera debate unlawful immigrant violence in 2007

[

Opinion

Examining the heated 2007 debate between Bill O'Reilly and Geraldo Rivera over the issue of illegal immigrants committing violent crimes in the United States.
Screenshot: Younger Turks

It is a clear demonstration of how America has been battling the issue of unlawful immigrants committing violent crimes on this nation for a while. We’ve got been speaking about this debate between former Fox Information hosts Invoice O'Reilly and Geraldo Rivera for nearly 20 years. Let's have a look. 12 months in the past.

Rivera has lengthy been an advocate for unlawful aliens, so it's no shock that on this 2007 clip he takes a stand in protection of a person convicted of homicide. He and O'Reilly started the talk by discussing Alfredo Ramos, who was sentenced to 24 years in jail after which ordered deported for the deaths of two teenage ladies in a drunken driving accident.

Earlier than the accident that took the ladies' lives, Ramos had beforehand been convicted of public intoxication, identification theft, in addition to three separate costs of DUI.

Regardless of his intensive prison historical past and unlawful standing within the nation earlier than the crash, Ramos was by no means reported to federal immigration authorities as a result of Virginia Seaside Police Division's “sanctuary coverage” applied in 2005, permitting authorities to confirm his immigration standing. Was stopped from even asking about it.

RELATED: Charles Payne assaults Geraldo Rivera with actuality: 'You assume Russia was going to bomb President Biden?!'

Riviera spars with O'Reilly – stops

Rivera in 2007 approached the story from the angle that the unlawful immigrant who killed two youngsters was no completely different from every other drunk driver in Virginia.

“I feel your story is totally flawed, my good friend. I feel we're speaking about drunk driving,” Rivera stated. “And within the 12 months 2005 there have been 347 drunk driving deaths within the Commonwealth of Virginia. “I feel this can be the primary drunk driving story out of Virginia.”

Ramos' case could be corresponding to different drunk driving instances provided that he weren’t An unlawful immigrant. You don't need to say, “Nicely, a financial institution robber could be no completely different from somebody making a withdrawal if he didn't have a gun.”

No, the financial institution robber is charged with theft And Illegal possession of a firearm, whereas the costs escalate to armed theft. That is related, Geraldo from 2007.

“That is no unlawful alien story, Invoice. It is a story about drunk driving,” Rivera stated wrongly.

“That's why you're flawed. If you enter this nation illegally, primary, you don’t have any proper to be right here, no rights. That's true,'' O'Reilly fired again in a debate that had grow to be extremely heated.

“Now, I simply need to make it clear. You, Geraldo Rivera, with teenage daughters, are telling me you don’t have any objection to somebody sneaking into the nation, getting drunk, being convicted of a DUI, and staying right here? He requested. “Are you okay with this?”

RELATED: ICE Boston brokers arrest unlawful alien convicted of sexually assaulting a baby: 'Critical menace'

Numerous tales of homicide and rape

When the primary method – classifying Ramos as any outdated drunk driving case – didn't work, Rivera tried to clarify to O'Reilly that the unlawful immigrant was being unfairly singled out due to his race. Is.

“My nightmare is that my daughters have something to do with somebody driving drunk. That is my nightmare,” he retorted. “It might be some Jewish drunkard. It might be a Polish drunkard. It might be an Irish drunk. This might be an Italian drunkard. What distinction does it make?”

The distinction is that he was right here illegally. Their nationality doesn’t matter.

“He has no proper to reside on this nation!” O'Reilly shouted.

The almost two-decade-old clip is exceptionally related given current information. We’ve got seen many examples in current instances of unlawful immigrants committing heinous crimes who “haven’t any proper to be on this nation”.

On Wednesday, The Political Insider reported on ICE Boston brokers arresting a 34-year-old Guatemalan unlawful immigrant who was lately convicted of assault and battery on a baby beneath 14. Regardless of the ERO, he was earlier launched by the Gloucester District Court docket. Enforcement and Removing Operations) Boston has filed an immigration detainer in opposition to him.

Moreover, authorities in Maryland arrested an unlawful immigrant from El Salvador and charged him with homicide within the case of a two-year-old boy who was shot to demise this month whereas strolling in a park along with his mom .

Not talked about is the case of Laken Riley, a College of Georgia nursing pupil who was allegedly killed by Jose Antonio Ibarra, an unlawful alien suspect.

Rivera, in 2007, wouldn’t discover these instances any extra newsworthy than in the event that they concerned an Irish individual.

Observe Rusty on X

'The game may be over': Supreme Court gives big win to Trump by agreeing to review presidential immunity

Now’s the time to help and share sources you belief.
The Political Insider is ranked #3 on Feedspot's “100 Greatest Political Blogs & Web sites”.

Rusty Weiss has been protecting politics for greater than 15 years. His work has appeared within the Every day Caller, Fox… and extra About Rusty Weiss

Leave a Comment