[
Civil liberties leaders like ACLU and Amnesty Worldwide are silent.
GUEST POST: By Roger Roots, J.D., Ph.D.
Each scholar of the First Modification is aware of concerning the notorious Alien and Sedition Acts, the Palmer Raids of World Battle I, the persecution of the Chicago 7, crackdowns on anti-war actions, and the FBI’s notorious COINTELPRO abuses and surveillance of Martin Luther King and the Black Panthers.
However the single biggest mass infringement on elementary First Modification freedoms is going on proper now. And the civil liberties institution, which rakes in thousands and thousands yearly parroting the civil rights speaking factors of the Seventies, has turned its again on the best mass political persecution in American authorized historical past: the railroading of January 6 defendants.
As these phrases are written, the US District Courtroom for DC is approaching a grim milestone. Someday within the subsequent few weeks, a complete of a thousand years of jail time could have been handed out to J6ers. January 6 injustices are eclipsing all different American authorized disgraces of the previous.
I actually am a J6 legal protection legal professional who has written a whole lot of motions and took part in eight J6 jury trials. Though I’ve a relatively successful report amongst different J6 protection attorneys—measured by complete counts defeated adversely—I and my co-counsels have nonetheless misplaced each case.
After three years of litigation, the conviction price for J6ers is one hundred pc earlier than juries; and 99.5 percent-plus earlier than judges. This will go down because the very highest conviction price for any particular class of legal case in any court docket venue in historical past. The DC venue doesn’t supply honest trials for opponents of the federal government who’re deemed to be conservative, rightwing, or Republican.
This will go down because the very highest conviction price for any particular class of legal case in any court docket venue in historical past. The DC venue doesn’t supply honest trials for opponents of the federal government who’re deemed to be conservative, rightwing, or Republican.
The common jail sentences for J6ers are by far the longest in American historical past related to rioting or demonstrating. Jail sentences related to the Civil Rights motion, anti-war riots, labor demonstrations, or Pink Scares don’t even come shut.
Not one of the Civil Battle’s Accomplice management served as a lot jail time as a mean J6er who merely pushed in opposition to a police riot protect exterior the Capitol on January 6. (Jefferson Davis himself served solely two years.)
The longest jail time period stemming from the notorious Alien and Sedition Act prosecutions of the 1790s—which each regulation scholar learns have been essentially the most tyrannical abuses of speech and political expression in early America—was 18 months. The longest time period served by Black Panthers who chased out the California legislature from the State Capitol with assault weapons in 1967 was one yr in jail.
Examine Eugene V. Debs’ ten-year jail sentence handed down in 1918 for sedition, to the 22-year jail sentence of Proud Boy chief Enrique Tarrio for seditious conspiracy stemming from January 6. Debs’ sedition conviction concerned claims that Debs’ anti-war speeches undermined America’s navy preparedness throughout World Battle I. (Notice that President Harding commuted Debs’ sentence in 1921.)
In the present day, civil libertarians regard Debs’ conviction as a stain on the historical past of the First Modification. However Enrique Tarrio wasn’t even on the Capitol on Jan. 6; he was watching the occasions on the information from a Baltimore motel room. Prosecutors cobbled collectively a “sedition” case from Tarrio’s social media posts and texts decrying 2020 election improprieties and usually praising the mass rebellion on January 6. (Tarrio didn’t testify however later mentioned the DOJ initially provided to launch him if he would simply say the Proud Boys attacked the Capitol upon Trump’s directions.)
Nothing—actually nothing—within the proof linked the Proud Boys to any definitive or detailed planning behind the chaotic breach of the Capitol on Jan. 6. Ethan Nordean, the highest-ranking Proud Boy on the scene, merely led followers in a rambling march across the Capitol whereas ingesting a can of Pabst Blue Ribbon. Nordean later entered the Capitol reluctantly, by way of a large open door, after a whole lot of others have been already in. Nordean is now serving 18 years.
The identical is true with Stewart Rhodes and the Oath Keepers. Rhodes is serving an 18-year jail sentence for seditious conspiracy regardless of by no means going within the Capitol and urging followers to not go inside. The Oath Keepers, in truth, offered precise safety for audio system at Trump’s rally earlier within the day—in coordination with the Secret Service—on the morning of January 6. However the Secret Service texts on January 6, together with texts concerning the discovering of pipe bombs at buildings adjoining to Capitol Grounds, have mysteriously gone lacking.
One J6er acquired 14 years for choosing up a discarded spray container and test-spraying it. One other J6er, actually dying of most cancers, was given 10 years for spraying pepper spray towards officers. The sort of pepper spray that may be bought at 7-11, over-the-counter. Jacob Chansley was given 40 months for the crime of demonstrating within the Capitol whereas carrying a wierd costume.
These lengthy jail sentences for J6ers are derived by making use of math tips to the sentencing tips. Judges stack enhancement upon enhancement to reach at stratospheric sentences, even for first-time offenders. For instance, judges utilized ridiculous “terrorism enhancements” to the Proud Boys and Oath Keepers by pointing to cases of property injury—such because the breaking of a window or the bending of an ornamental fence—after which attributing such property injury to “intimidation or coercion.” A number of Proud Boys, akin to Tarrio and my shopper, Dominic Pezzola, didn’t even contact the fence they have been accused of destroying; however jurors convicted them on strained “aiding and abetting” theories. (Tarrio was some 40 miles away on the time.)
Journalist Steve Baker has documented that prosecutors and authorities witnesses dedicated blatant perjury at Rhodes’ trial, and even introduced false proof that Oath Keepers terrorized a black officer contained in the Capitol. However slightly than examine such perjury, the Division of Justice selected to cost Baker, the investigative journalist, with crimes.
Mainstream information media dutifully experiences these exorbitant jail sentences as if the judges are being lenient to J6 defendants for issuing sentences beneath prosecutors’ suggestions or “the Tips.” Readers are left pondering Guideline ranges are calculated mechanically. The Tips don’t dictate exact sentences however direct customers to use analogous sentences to crimes that aren’t specified within the handbook. In each J6 case of disorderly conduct (a misdemeanor not specified within the handbook), judges and prosecutors have utilized a tenet vary that applies to assaulting officers (a felony). And plenty of judges punish J6 defendants with “obstruction of justice” enhancements if the defendants dare to testify in their very own protection however are later (nearly inevitably, given the venue) convicted.
Nearly everybody who even touched a cop or pushed in opposition to a police protect on Jan. 6 is charged with assaulting a federal officer. After their near-certain convictions, these J6ers discover their sentences are enhanced or designated as aggravated assault for sentencing functions, upon a concept that they chose their “sufferer” because of his “official standing” or dedicated the crime with the “intent to commit one other felony.” Dozens of bogus assaulting-officers-with-deadly-and-dangerous-weapon convictions are based mostly on acts akin to spraying totally nondeadly pepper spray or tossing a visitors cone or a plastic water bottle. One J6 participant named Ronald McAbee was even convicted of assaulting cops with a “lethal and harmful weapon” for carrying biker gloves with bolstered knuckles—regardless of by no means punching anybody with the gloves.
The cruelty of prosecutorial vindictiveness in opposition to J6ers has completely evaded the eye of America’s civil liberties institution. Neither ACLU nor another group purportedly preventing injustice has bothered to note. No less than sixteen J6ers who rejected authorities misdemeanor plea provides concerning their misdemeanor prices discovered themselves out of the blue charged with felonies as punishment. These superseding indictments ceaselessly land instantly previous to the anticipated misdemeanor trial; accompanied by prosecutors’ insistence on no continuance of the trial date for the defendant to arrange in opposition to the brand new prices.
The DC jury pool is essentially the most excessive pro-government jury pool in the US, if not anyplace exterior North Korea. DC residents vote for Democrats greater than 90 p.c of the time. Current polling reveals that just about half of DC residents assume “life imprisonment or dying” could be “a good punishment” for J6ers. Nearly 70 p.c of DC residents consider “anybody who participated within the occasions” ought to serve laborious time in jail.
That is whereas the remainder of the nation has softened discernably concerning J6ers. A USA/Suffolk College ballot performed on the 3-year anniversary of the occasion discovered that simply 48 p.c of nationwide voters mentioned they thought the rioters have been “criminals,” a major drop from a survey performed simply after January 6.
Prosecutors know they’ll indict and convict a ham sandwich in DC (as long as they label the sandwich a Republican). I lately tried a J6 case involving a DC Metro cop who grabbed my shopper’s tiny fiberglass flagpole, maliciously broke it in two, and reduce his finger on the fiberglass. My shopper is now jailed for “assaulting a federal officer, inflicting bodily damage”—probably the most critical prices within the U.S. Prison Code, awaiting sentencing. The bodycam footage clearly confirmed the officer holding the flagpole between his two palms when he broke it.
I beforehand tried one other case the place a J6er excitedly spoke into his cellphone throughout a Fb dwell stream, issues akin to “We’re storming the Capitol!” and “They will’t cease us!” whereas strolling exterior the constructing. Possible, nobody round him might have even heard his statements; and a authorities official admitted that nobody contained in the constructing might have probably heard the remarks. Nonetheless, the shopper was convicted of “obstruction of an official continuing” and now awaits sentencing (as much as 20 years).
Usually, this lopsided imbalance would provoke judges to step as much as shield the rights of defendants. However within the instances of January 6 defendants, the judges have typically joined forces with prosecutors to maximise convictions and sentences. For instance, J6 judges have essentially altered the essential regulation of pretrial detention and bail in J6 instances to detain extra J6ers earlier than trial. A number of DC federal judges have used their benches as pulpits from which to denounce J6ers as insurrectionists and condemn “conspiracy theories” about covert authorities planning on January 6.
“Conspiracy theories,” not less than such theories that problem authorities narratives, are by no means, ever, ever, given any listening to within the District Courts of D.C. Any questions concerning the elusive pipe bomb “investigation,” or the presence of a whole lot of undercover authorities brokers among the many rioters are strictly forbidden. Prosecutors object immediately at any time when a protection lawyer asks about such issues; and judges instantly maintain the objections.
A few of the most vital instigators of the Capitol breach on Jan. 6 have by no means been apprehended, regardless of their options being plainly seen to thousands and thousands on broadly circulated movies. The truth that Vice President-Elect Kamala Harris was at DNC Headquarters close to the “pipe bombs,” as an alternative of the Capitol, on the most vital moments of January 6, was saved prime secret for nearly a yr after the occasion. Tons of of indictments—which falsely mentioned Harris was within the Capitol—needed to be rewritten. Which means that a whole lot of grand jurors have been lied to or misled; and that grand juries needed to be recalled and re-instructed, at a possible price of thousands and thousands of {dollars}. The general public nonetheless has not been offered any rationalization.
By now it’s apparent even to members of Congress that the “pipe bombs” have been really some sort of blown sting operation or undercover FBI or Secret Service false-flag operation. However each query concerning the episode goes unanswered. Way back the FBI launched video of the “pipe bomber” that was intentionally grainy—at a body price slower than any video digicam offered at WalMart. The FBI director informed Congressman Massie that it was unable to trace the “pipe bomber’s” cellphone as a result of the cellphone’s sign was “corrupted.”
January 6 prosecutions have shattered boundaries of normalcy concerning legal justice. Pre-dawn raids with flash-bang grenades and armored automobiles had by no means beforehand been used for misdemeanor arrests. Actually, nearly no retiree of the FBI remembers the company ever really arresting anybody for misdemeanors. Up to now, such petty prices have been typically initiated by citations.
For J6 investigations, the FBI has employed the biggest and most open-ended search warrants in historical past—so-called “geo-fence” warrants which compelled Google, AT&T, Verizon and different cell service suppliers to reveal location information of each cellphone close to the Capitol on that day. These have been primarily the biggest common warrants in human historical past; based mostly on the premise that anybody who confirmed up needs to be investigated for against the law—to be decided later.
Mentioning the First Modification is Prohibited.
Prosecutors file motions to forbid mentioning the First Modification prior to each trial. Judges grant the motions nearly summarily. Prosecutors then use the judges’ orders as an offensive weapon. I lately tried a J6 case the place a prosecutor repeatedly assured the jury throughout closing argument that the defendant was “not” protesting. (The decide’s pretrial ruling was that the defendant’s actions akin to holding a flag and chanting political slogans had no constitutional safety in any respect and that the defendant was solely on the Capitol to assault, terrorize, impede or disrupt.) So the prosecutor knew that she might falsely inform the jury that my shopper “was not” protesting whereas the protection couldn’t inform the jury that the shopper “was” protesting.
Equally, federal prosecutors are in a position to introduce any of a J6 defendant’s social media posts about ‘stopping the steal’ as proof of the defendant’s corrupt intent to “overturn” an election; however defendants are prohibited from introducing different social media posts exhibiting their good religion foundation for his or her beliefs.
January 6 prosecutors and judges assert that J6 defendants forfeited all their First Modification rights by breaking petty guidelines regarding trespassing or disrupting sacred authorities proceedings. Lengthy-settled First Modification choices by the U.S. Supreme Courtroom have been forged apart. For instance, in Adderley v. State of Fla. (1966), the Supreme Courtroom upheld trespassing convictions of protestors at a Florida jail however mentioned the defendants could be protected by the First Modification if the power had been a legislative capitol.
Keep tuned!
Roger Roots is a companion with John Pierce Legislation. He has represented over a dozen January 6 defendants over the previous two years.