[
Angela Chao on the New York Metropolis Opera Pre-Gala Ceremony in 2010. In February 2024, Chao drowned after unintentionally overturning her Tesla in a pond in Texas.Patrick McMullan/Getty Photographs
- Transport magnate Angela Chao drowned final month after unintentionally crashing her Tesla right into a pond.
- She advised a buddy that she typically unintentionally places the automotive in reverse as an alternative of driving.
- Tesla house owners have reported comparable issues to the Federal Transportation Security Board.
Tesla house owners expressed concern for years about design flaws and seeming malfunctions that brought about them to unintentionally drive in reverse, earlier than the loss of life of transport magnate Angela Chao, who died final month after unintentionally crashing her Tesla right into a pond. She drowned later.
Whereas leaving a celebration at a farm outdoors Austin final month, Chao tried to make a three-point flip along with her Tesla Mannequin X SUV, The Wall Avenue Journal stories. However as an alternative of placing the automotive in drive, he unintentionally put it in reverse. The automotive went by an embankment and right into a pond.
The error was deadly. But it surely wasn't the primary time Chao had unintentionally reversed the automotive, the Journal stories.
Neither is Chao the one one that has issues with Tesla gearshifts. Enterprise Insider discovered 12 complaints associated to the Tesla reverse perform in a database of vehicle client complaints maintained by the U.S. Division of Transportation.
Seven of these complaints have been from individuals who mentioned the way in which Tesla designed the gearshift was complicated, typically leading to them having to place the automotive in drive when they need to have put it in reverse or vice versa. used to have. The opposite 5 complaints have been from individuals who mentioned their vehicles appeared to modify between drive and reverse with out warning.
The difficulty has even reached Tesla boards, the place a Tesla proprietor in 2022 wrote that thrice within the two years he owned the automotive he “unintentionally began to reverse as an alternative of drive”.
One other Tesla proprietor wrote in 2022 that they “nearly crashed” resulting from confusion over the right way to put the automotive in reverse. One other person responded, “I did one thing comparable throughout the first month of proudly owning my automotive.”
Nonetheless, within the context of notoriously small autos, reverse-shifting points are comparatively small potatoes. The federal database the place BI found 12 issues about reverse shifting had a complete of 4,228 complaints associated to Tesla.
By comparability, the DOT obtained greater than 700 complaints about so-called “phantom braking,” or the tendency of Teslas with Autopilot engaged to slam on the brakes for imaginary hazards throughout the full movement of visitors. A minimum of one individual in a Tesla died on account of Phantom braking. Regulators start investigation into phantom braking in Teslas in 2022.
Tesla didn’t reply to Enterprise Insider's request for remark. The Nationwide Freeway Site visitors Security Administration, the Transportation Division bureau that investigates car defects, didn’t reply to a request for remark.
Relying on the mannequin and 12 months, Teslas have two totally different gearshifts. It’s unclear which mannequin 12 months Chao was driving, however each mechanisms have generated complaints.
Earlier than the tip of 2021, drivers of all Teslas went into reverse by urgent the brake pedal and flicking a gear stalk upward on the correct facet of the steering wheel – a movement that some complainants mentioned was complicated, as a result of For some fashions and years, the identical pace the gear stalk turns off the automotive's autopilot mode when the brake isn’t pressed.
A driver of a Tesla Mannequin Y mentioned he unintentionally reversed the automotive whereas ready at a stoplight in a 2022, thereby avoiding a collision.
When the sunshine turned inexperienced, he “instinctively” jerked the right-hand gear stalk upward to disengage the autopilot so he may flip left, he advised the DOT.
“Sadly, this 'conditioned' conduct of mine inadvertently brought about the automotive to reverse!! I pressed the accelerator and nearly bumped into the automotive behind me,” the complainant wrote to the company. “I'm 99% certain my foot wasn't on the brake pedal as a result of I not often use it lately,” he wrote. he wrote, noting that they depend on the automotive's autopilot mode to use the brakes.
“Whereas I actually understand that I’m solely chargeable for the confusion, I’m assured that Tesla security engineers wish to discover this state of affairs and search a preventive safety-guard,” he continued. “Possibly software program may forestall the automotive from reversing except the brake pedal is depressed. Or perhaps a really giant “R” indicator that blinks and beeps. I'm certain that's a straightforward answer.”
Tesla Mannequin Drivers put the automotive in reverse by knocking down on an icon on the middle console. That change additionally generated complaints.
A Tesla driver advised the DOT in 2022 that the touchscreen gearshift was “unclear and harmful”, including that he “had a small incident with him not shifting whereas driving, getting caught in reverse after which parking at low pace Collided with a parked car.”